Where Money Came From · Lesson 34 · 12 min read

Floating and Pegged

What Force Is Setting This Price?
Kanin D. Alldredge
Legal & Quantitative Analyst / Author / Educator, The Currency Classroom
Free

1The Question Before the Chart

Most traders open a pair and ask which way it is going.

There is a question that comes before that one, and skipping it causes a specific kind of expensive mistake.

What force is actually setting this price?

For EUR/USD the answer is straightforward. Supply and demand, from millions of participants, as Lesson 5 described.

For a lot of the world's tradeable currencies, that is not the answer. The price on the screen is being held, steered, or bounded by an institution making decisions.

Figure 34.1: Before asking which way a pair is going, ask what force is setting its price.
Figure 34.1Before asking which way a pair is going, ask what force is setting its price.

Assuming every price is a market price is an analytical error. It is not a rare one. It applies to a large share of what you can trade.

2A Spectrum, Not a Binary

It is tempting to sort currencies into floating and fixed. The reality runs along a line, with more institutional control at each step down.

RegimeWho Sets the PriceExample
Free floatThe market, with occasional tactical interventionEUR/USD, GBP/USD, USD/JPY
Managed floatThe market, within a framework a central bank steersUSD/CNH
Hard pegThe central bank, defending a declared rate or bandUSD/HKD, USD/SAR (a currency board is the strictest hard peg)
Currency boardA legal mechanism, backing every unit with reservesHong Kong dollar, Bosnian convertible mark
Figure 34.2: Exchange rate regimes run along a spectrum of institutional control.
Figure 34.2Exchange rate regimes run along a spectrum of institutional control.

Each step down changes what moves the price, which tools read it, and what the risk looks like.

Take them in turn.

3Free Float, With an Asterisk

A free-floating currency has its rate set primarily by market forces. The majors from Lesson 7 all sit here.

But the word free is doing less work than it appears, and this catches people out.

Central banks of free-floating currencies do intervene. Japan has done so repeatedly to manage yen volatility, and it is not alone. No major central bank has promised never to intervene.

So the distinction is not whether intervention happens. It is what kind.

Free FloatManaged Float
Intervention isTactical and occasionalStructural and sustained
Its purposeTo calm disorderly conditionsTo hold the rate within a framework
Between interventionsThe market sets the priceThe framework still applies

A free float can be intervened in. A managed float is being managed whether or not anyone is intervening today.

Figure 34.3: A free float sees occasional intervention, while a managed float is steered every day.
Figure 34.3A free float sees occasional intervention, while a managed float is steered every day.

4Managed Float

Most of the world's currencies sit somewhere in this middle ground. China's arrangement is the largest, and the clearest illustration of how the pieces fit.

ComponentWhat It Does
A daily reference rateThe central bank publishes a fixing each day, declaring where it considers the rate should sit
Very large reservesAround $3.1 trillion as of early 2025, which is the firepower to intervene at scale if required
Capital controlsRestrictions on moving money in and out, which limit how much pressure can build against the rate

Those three work as a system. The fixing declares the intent. The reserves back it. The controls limit who can push against it.

Figure 34.4: China's fixing, reserves and capital controls work as one system.
Figure 34.4China's fixing, reserves and capital controls work as one system.

For a trader this changes the analysis rather than ruling it out. Technical tools still tell you something, because a real market operates inside the framework. But the framework is a force no chart can show you, and it is often the larger one.

Figure 34.5: In a managed float, a real market moves inside a framework the chart cannot show.
Figure 34.5In a managed float, a real market moves inside a framework the chart cannot show.

5Hard Pegs

A hard peg is a declared commitment to hold a specific rate or a narrow band, defended indefinitely.

Lesson 10 introduced the example. The Hong Kong dollar has been pegged to the US dollar since 1983, and held within a band of 7.75 to 7.85 since 2005.

Pull that chart up and it looks like a flat line. Almost nothing happens, for years at a time.

That flatness is not low volatility. It is institutional constraint, drawn as a price.

Figure 34.6: On the same percentage scale, a hard peg barely moves next to a free float.
Figure 34.6On the same percentage scale, a hard peg barely moves next to a free float.

Which changes what there is to analyze. On a hard peg the price barely moves, so watching it tells you little. What moves is the stress on the commitment. How hard the market is testing it, and how expensive the defense has become.

That stress is measurable. It just is not measurable on the chart.

Figure 34.7: On a hard peg, what moves is the stress on the commitment, not the price.
Figure 34.7On a hard peg, what moves is the stress on the commitment, not the price.

6Currency Boards

A currency board goes one step further, and the difference is not a matter of degree.

Under a currency board, every unit of domestic currency must be backed by foreign reserves at a fixed rate. The currency cannot be issued unless the foreign currency is received in exchange. The arrangement is written into law.

Figure 34.8: A currency board can issue domestic currency only against foreign currency received.
Figure 34.8A currency board can issue domestic currency only against foreign currency received.

The consequences are strict. The authority cannot print money to fund government spending. It cannot run its own monetary policy. It cannot move the rate without legislation.

Figure 34.9: A conventional peg has a decision point. A currency board does not.
Figure 34.9A conventional peg has a decision point. A currency board does not.

Hong Kong has run one since 1983, backing every Hong Kong dollar with US dollars in its Exchange Fund. Bulgaria ran one from 1997, after a currency crisis, holding the lev first against the Deutsche Mark and then the euro at a rate carried to five decimal places, until it adopted the euro itself in January 2026.

7Three Ways to Defend a Rate

Whatever the regime, a central bank holding a rate has three tools. Each one works. Each has a cost and a limit.

ToolHow It WorksWhat It Costs
Reserve interventionBuy your own currency with foreign reserves to support itReserves are finite. Every defense spends some.
Interest rate policyRaise rates to make holding the currency more attractiveHigher rates slow the domestic economy, whatever it needs
Capital controlsRestrict money moving across the borderDeters foreign investment and limits domestic freedom
Figure 34.10: Each of the three tools for defending a rate works, and each has a cost.
Figure 34.10Each of the three tools for defending a rate works, and each has a cost.

The second tool has a deeper consequence, and it is permanent rather than occasional.

A country that fixes to another currency imports that country's monetary conditions. Hong Kong's interest rates must broadly follow the Federal Reserve, because any real divergence would create capital flows that pressure the peg.

So when the Fed raised rates sharply in 2022 and 2023, Hong Kong had to follow, whatever local conditions wanted. That is the standing price of the arrangement, not an occasional inconvenience.

Figure 34.11: A pegged currency imports the anchor country's interest rates.
Figure 34.11A pegged currency imports the anchor country's interest rates.

The third tool changes the size of the problem more than the others. If capital cannot leave freely, the pressure is limited to trade flows rather than the full weight of global finance. That is the difference between a contained problem and an open flank.

Figure 34.12: Capital controls limit pressure to trade flows rather than the full weight of global finance.
Figure 34.12Capital controls limit pressure to trade flows rather than the full weight of global finance.

8What Regime Changes About Your Analysis

Here is the practical payoff, and it is the reason this lesson exists in a trading course rather than an economics one.

If the Regime IsThen
A free floatEverything in this course applies in full. Supply and demand are real, and the chart reflects genuine market opinion.
A managed floatCharts retain partial value, but the institutional framework is a force they cannot show. Policy direction and reserve trends sit alongside the chart.
A hard peg or currency boardThe chart is not the primary tool. Reserve data, interest rate differentials, and the cost of defense are what tell you anything.
Figure 34.13: The further down the spectrum, the less of the work the chart can do.
Figure 34.13The further down the spectrum, the less of the work the chart can do.

Read the last row against Lesson 3, which taught you to read a chart, and Lesson 10, which warned that some prices are held rather than free. On a hard peg the chart tells you only whether the commitment is still holding. It cannot tell you whether it will hold tomorrow.

Figure 34.14: On an unfamiliar exotic pair, the safer assumption is that active management is present.
Figure 34.14On an unfamiliar exotic pair, the safer assumption is that active management is present.

None of which makes pegged currencies untradeable. It makes them a different problem, needing different information. The mistake is not trading them. The mistake is trading them as though they were EUR/USD.

Which leaves the question this lesson has been circling. Every one of these commitments is defended by an institution with finite resources and real costs. So what happens when the defense fails?

That is the next lesson, and it contains two of the largest single-day moves in the history of currency markets.

Three Things to Remember

Try This

Fifteen minutes. Build the habit of asking the prior question.

Words From This Lesson

TermWhat It Means
Exchange rate regimeThe arrangement determining how a currency's rate is set, from free floating to legally fixed.
Free floatA rate set primarily by market forces, with occasional tactical intervention.
Managed floatA rate that moves with the market inside a framework a central bank actively steers.
Hard pegA declared commitment to hold a specific rate or narrow band, defended indefinitely.
Currency boardA peg written into law, with every unit of currency backed by foreign reserves. No discretionary decision point.
Reserve interventionBuying or selling your own currency using foreign reserves to influence its rate.
Capital controlsRestrictions on moving money across a border, which limit pressure that can build against a rate.
Peg stressHow hard the market is testing a commitment, and how costly the defense is becoming.

Test Your Knowledge

Eight questions. Answer them all before checking the key on the following pages. If a question gives you trouble, the answer key tells you which section to revisit.

1. What is the first question to ask before trading a pair?
  1. A. Which direction is it heading
  2. B. What is the current spread
  3. C. What force is actually setting this price
  4. D. Which session is most active
2. Does a free-floating currency ever see central bank intervention?
  1. A. No, by definition
  2. B. Only if the IMF approves
  3. C. Only during declared crises
  4. D. Yes, tactically and occasionally
3. What distinguishes a managed float from a free float?
  1. A. Managed floats have wider spreads
  2. B. Intervention is structural and sustained rather than tactical
  3. C. Managed floats cannot be traded by retail participants
  4. D. Free floats have no central bank
4. USD/HKD trades in a very narrow range for years. What does that flatness represent?
  1. A. Institutional constraint expressed as price behavior
  2. B. Unusually low market volatility
  3. C. A data error on the chart
  4. D. Lack of trading interest in the pair
5. What makes a currency board more durable than a conventional peg?
  1. A. It holds larger reserves
  2. B. It is supported by the IMF
  3. C. Every unit is mechanically backed, removing the discretionary decision point
  4. D. It permits a wider band
6. What are the three tools for defending a fixed rate?
  1. A. Devaluation, revaluation, and floating
  2. B. Spread widening, margin calls, trading halts
  3. C. Inflation targeting, bond issuance, taxation
  4. D. Reserve intervention, interest rate policy, capital controls
7. What is the permanent cost of pegging to another currency?
  1. A. Higher inflation, always
  2. B. Importing the anchor country's monetary conditions
  3. C. Loss of foreign investment
  4. D. Mandatory capital controls
8. For a hard peg, what is the primary analytical tool?
  1. A. Reserve data, rate differentials, and the cost of defense
  2. B. The price chart
  3. C. Candlestick patterns
  4. D. Session timing

Answer Key

Each answer explains why the correct choice is correct, why the others are not, and where to reread.

Question 1 · correct answer C

The regime determines which analytical tools apply, what the risk looks like, and what needs monitoring. Direction is the second question, not the first.

A is what most traders ask first, which is the habit this lesson exists to change. B and D are real pre-trade checks from Series B and D, but neither tells you what kind of price you are looking at.

Review: Section 1, The Question Before the Chart

Question 2 · correct answer D

Major central banks do intervene, and Japan has done so repeatedly. No major central bank has committed to never intervening under any circumstances.

A takes the word free too literally, which is exactly the trap. C narrows it too far, since intervention is not restricted to declared crises. B invents an approval process that does not exist.

Review: Section 3, Free Float, With an Asterisk

Question 3 · correct answer B

A free float can be intervened in occasionally. A managed float is being managed continuously, whether or not intervention happens on any given day.

A describes a cost difference that does not define the regime. C is wrong because managed float currencies are widely traded. D is wrong because free floating countries have central banks too.

Review: Section 3, Free Float, With an Asterisk

Question 4 · correct answer A

The narrow range exists because an authority defends the band edges. The flatness is the constraint made visible, not an absence of forces acting on the pair.

B describes the appearance and misses the cause. C mistakes a real and deliberate outcome for an error. D is wrong because the pair is actively traded.

Review: Section 5, Hard Pegs

Question 5 · correct answer C

A conventional peg is a promise with a committee behind it, and committees can decide the cost has become too high. A currency board backs every unit mechanically, so no such decision point exists.

A is not the distinguishing feature, since reserve size varies in both arrangements. B is wrong because IMF support does not define a currency board. D reverses it, as currency boards are stricter rather than looser.

Review: Section 6, Currency Boards

Question 6 · correct answer D

Buying your own currency with reserves, raising rates to make it attractive to hold, and restricting cross-border flows. Each works, and each has a cost and a limit.

B lists things brokers and exchanges do, not central banks. C lists genuine policy tools that are not the mechanisms for defending a rate. A lists outcomes rather than defenses.

Review: Section 7, Three Ways to Defend a Rate

Question 7 · correct answer B

Fixing to another currency means following its monetary conditions, because any real divergence creates capital flows that pressure the peg. Hong Kong had to follow the Fed through 2022 and 2023 regardless of local conditions.

A is not automatic, and pegs are often adopted to control inflation. C describes a possible effect of capital controls rather than of pegging. D is wrong because capital controls are a choice, not a requirement.

Review: Section 7, Three Ways to Defend a Rate

Question 8 · correct answer A

On a hard peg the price barely moves, so the chart only tells you whether the commitment is still holding. Whether it will continue to hold shows up in reserves and the cost of defense.

B is the intuitive answer and the one that misses what is actually happening. C and D are tools built for market-determined prices, which is not what a hard peg produces.

Review: Section 8, What Regime Changes About Your Analysis

Keep going

Where Money Came From is written by Kanin D. Alldredge for The Currency Classroom, and it is free to read. There is more free from CNS: start here.

Start free with CNS →

Or see CNS Pro →