Where Money Came From · Lesson 30 · 12 min read

Where Money Comes From

And Why Yours Is Designed to Shrink
Kanin D. Alldredge
Legal & Quantitative Analyst / Author / Educator, The Currency Classroom
Free

1The Model Most People Carry

Ask where money comes from and most people describe roughly the same picture. The government prints it. A central bank oversees the process. Money enters the world at a press and spreads outward.

That picture is not exactly wrong. It is incomplete because it misses where most money actually comes from.

Most money is not printed. It is lent into existence.

Figure 30.1: Most money is created when banks lend, not when a press prints it.
Figure 30.1Most money is created when banks lend, not when a press prints it.

That sounds like a provocation. It is just a description of how banking works, and central banks say so themselves. The Bank of England has published it in plain language.

Working out how takes one example.

2Every Loan Creates a Deposit

Picture a bank approving a mortgage. Two hundred thousand.

The intuitive assumption is that the bank finds two hundred thousand somewhere, perhaps from other customers' savings, and hands it over. Money moves from one place to another.

That is not what happens. The bank types a number into an account.

loan approved → new deposit appears → money supply grows

The deposit did not exist before the loan was approved. It was not taken from anywhere. It was created at the moment of approval. The money supply in that economy is now two hundred thousand larger than it was that morning.

Figure 30.2: Approving a loan creates the loan and a matching new deposit at the same moment.
Figure 30.2Approving a loan creates the loan and a matching new deposit at the same moment.

The process runs backward too. When the loan is repaid, that money is extinguished rather than passed along. The supply shrinks.

Which produces a picture quite different from a printing press.

WhenWhat Happens to the Money Supply
Banks lend freely and borrowing is in demandIt expands
Credit tightens, or loans are repaid faster than new ones are madeIt contracts

The total money in an economy is not a fixed amount controlled from above. It breathes, and it breathes with lending.

Figure 30.3: The money supply expands with lending and contracts when credit tightens.
Figure 30.3The money supply expands with lending and contracts when credit tightens.

3What Central Banks Actually Control

So what does a central bank do, if it is not making most of the money?

It controls the base and influences everything above it, using two main tools.

Figure 30.4: A central bank works through its base rate and its operations in the bond market.
Figure 30.4A central bank works through its base rate and its operations in the bond market.
ToolHow It WorksEffect
The base interest rateSets what banks pay to borrow overnightRaise it and lending slows. Cut it and lending accelerates.
Open market operationsBuys or sells government bonds and other assetsBuying injects new reserves. Selling withdraws them.

The first is the lever from Lesson 1, seen from the other side. Raising rates attracts money to a currency, so the currency strengthens. It also makes borrowing more expensive across the system, which slows the pace at which banks create new money.

So an interest rate decision does two things at once. It changes what holding the currency pays, and it changes how fast new currency is coming into existence.

Figure 30.5: A rate rise strengthens the currency and slows the creation of new money.
Figure 30.5A rate rise strengthens the currency and slows the creation of new money.
Figure 30.6: Quantitative easing adds reserves, and quantitative tightening withdraws them.
Figure 30.6Quantitative easing adds reserves, and quantitative tightening withdraws them.

4Measuring the Money

Because the money supply moves, it gets measured. There are four common measures, three of them nested inside each other, and they turn up constantly in central bank language.

MeasureWhat It IncludesWho Controls It
M0Physical cash plus bank reserves at the central bankThe central bank, directly
M1Cash in circulation plus current accounts and instantly spendable depositsMostly the banking system
M2In most definitions, M1 plus savings accounts, money market accounts, short-term depositsMostly the banking system
M3M2 plus large time deposits and less liquid instrumentsMostly the banking system

Only the first line is under direct control. Everything below it grows and shrinks with lending. That is why central banks influence the money supply rather than set it.

Figure 30.7: M1 to M3 nest inside each other. M0 shares only the cash, because bank reserves are not part of M1.
Figure 30.7M1 to M3 nest inside each other. M0 shares only the cash, because bank reserves are not part of M1.

The one to remember is M2. It is the most widely watched measure in the United States and most major economies. When someone mentions money supply growth without saying which, they usually mean this.

If You SeeIt Signals
M2 growing rapidly relative to economic outputInflationary pressure building
M2 contractingA deflationary warning, and usually economic stress

That one line of vocabulary turns a lot of opaque commentary into something readable. The European Central Bank tracks M3 as its main broad measure. The US Federal Reserve stopped publishing M3 in 2006, judging M2 sufficient.

Figure 30.8: What fast M2 growth and an M2 contraction usually signal.
Figure 30.8What fast M2 growth and an M2 contraction usually signal.

5Why Two Percent

Nearly every major central bank targets inflation of about two percent a year.

Which invites an obvious question. If inflation erodes what money buys, why aim for any at all? Why not zero, so that money holds its value?

There are two primary reasons, and a third practical reason.

The first is that mild inflation discourages sitting on money. If prices will be slightly higher next year, holding cash has a small cost and putting it to work has a small advantage. Multiply that nudge across an economy and it keeps capital moving.

The second is about what happens on the other side of zero, and central banks consider it much more dangerous.

Figure 30.9: Deflation feeds itself, which is why central banks keep inflation above zero.
Figure 30.9Deflation feeds itself, which is why central banks keep inflation above zero.

Now the third, more practical reason. Targeting two percent leaves room to cut rates when the economy slows. A bank already at zero has far less to work with when something goes wrong.

Figure 30.10: Keeping rates above zero leaves room to cut when the economy slows.
Figure 30.10Keeping rates above zero leaves room to cut when the economy slows.

6Your Money Is Designed to Shrink

Follow that policy through and you arrive somewhere uncomfortable.

If the target is two percent and it is broadly hit, money loses value every year. Not through failure. Not through mismanagement. Not by accident.

Every fiat currency is expected to lose purchasing power. That is the design.

Here is what two percent a year actually does to a hundred dollars left alone.

After$100 Buys What This Buys Today
1 year$98
5 years$91
10 years$82
20 years$67
35 years$50

Thirty-five years to halve. Which is roughly one working life.

Figure 30.11: At 2% a year, $100 buys about half as much after thirty-five years.
Figure 30.11At 2% a year, $100 buys about half as much after thirty-five years.

This is what purchasing power means, and it is the idea Lesson 2 set aside. A dollar is always a dollar. What a dollar buys is a different question, and it has a consistent answer over long periods.

7Why This Reaches a Chart

All of which connects back to the pair in front of you, in three ways.

The first is that money supply figures are a forward signal. When M2 grows faster than what an economy produces, more currency chases the same goods. That pushes prices up and the currency's value down, and it shows up in exchange rates.

The second is that inflation targets are why rate decisions happen at all. A central bank raising rates is usually responding to inflation above target, and Lesson 1 established what raising rates does to a currency. The target is the reason behind the reason.

The third connects to Lesson 29. Every pair compares two monetary systems, and now you can see more of what that means. Two rates of money creation. Two inflation outcomes against two targets. Two institutions with different records of hitting them.

A currency pair is two rates of erosion, measured against each other.

Both currencies in any pair are losing purchasing power by design. What the exchange rate reports is which one is losing it faster, and how expectations about that are shifting.

Figure 30.12: A pair reports which of two currencies is losing purchasing power faster.
Figure 30.12A pair reports which of two currencies is losing purchasing power faster.

The next lesson goes back to before any of this existed, to when money was metal and the amount that could exist depended on what came out of the ground.

Three Things to Remember

Try This

Fifteen minutes and a calculator. Make the erosion your own number.

Words From This Lesson

TermWhat It Means
Credit creationThe process by which commercial bank lending creates new money in the form of new deposits.
Monetary basePhysical currency plus bank reserves held at the central bank. Measured as M0.
M2The most widely watched broad money measure. Currency, current accounts, savings, and short-term deposits.
Open market operationsA central bank buying or selling assets to inject or withdraw reserves from the banking system.
Quantitative easingLarge-scale asset buying by a central bank to expand the monetary base, used when rate cuts have run out of room.
Inflation targetThe rate of inflation a central bank aims for. Approximately two percent in most major economies.
DeflationFalling prices. Self-reinforcing and considered considerably more dangerous than moderate inflation.
Purchasing powerWhat a unit of currency will actually buy. Falls over time by design under an inflation target.

Test Your Knowledge

Eight questions. Answer them all before checking the key on the following pages. If a question gives you trouble, the answer key tells you which section to revisit.

1. Who creates most of the money in a modern economy?
  1. A. The central bank, through printing
  2. B. International institutions
  3. C. The government, through spending
  4. D. Commercial banks, through lending
2. What happens when a bank approves a loan?
  1. A. It transfers money from savers to the borrower
  2. B. It requests the funds from the central bank
  3. C. It creates a new deposit, which is new money
  4. D. It draws down its physical cash reserves
3. What happens to the money supply when loans are repaid faster than new ones are made?
  1. A. It expands
  2. B. It stays constant
  3. C. It contracts
  4. D. It depends on the interest rate
4. Which money supply measure is most widely watched?
  1. A. M0
  2. B. M2
  3. C. M1
  4. D. M3
5. M2 is contracting. What does this signal?
  1. A. Inflationary pressure
  2. B. A deflationary warning and likely economic stress
  3. C. A stronger currency, reliably
  4. D. Nothing meaningful
6. Why do central banks target two percent inflation rather than zero?
  1. A. It discourages hoarding and keeps a buffer above deflation
  2. B. Two percent is the historical average
  3. C. It maximizes government tax revenue
  4. D. It is required by international agreement
7. At two percent inflation, roughly how long does money take to halve in purchasing power?
  1. A. About 10 years
  2. B. About 20 years
  3. C. About 70 years
  4. D. About 35 years
8. What does an exchange rate report about two currencies losing purchasing power?
  1. A. Which is losing it faster, and how expectations are shifting
  2. B. Which one is not losing value
  3. C. That one of them must be gaining value
  4. D. Nothing, since inflation does not affect exchange rates

Answer Key

Each answer explains why the correct choice is correct, why the others are not, and where to reread.

Question 1 · correct answer D

The majority of money in circulation is created by commercial banks extending loans. Central banks confirm this in their own published research.

A describes the model most people carry, which accounts for only the monetary base. C describes fiscal activity, which spends money rather than creating it. B is wrong because no international body creates a country's money supply.

Review: Section 1, The Model Most People Carry

Question 2 · correct answer C

The bank creates a deposit in the borrower's account. That deposit did not exist beforehand and was not taken from anywhere, so the money supply grows.

A is the intuitive assumption and the one this section corrects. B is wrong because the loan does not require central bank funds. D is wrong because almost none of this involves physical cash.

Review: Section 2, Every Loan Creates a Deposit

Question 3 · correct answer C

Repayment extinguishes money rather than passing it along. If repayment outpaces new lending, the supply shrinks.

A describes the opposite situation, when lending outpaces repayment. B treats the supply as fixed, which it is not. D confuses a driver of lending with the outcome itself.

Review: Section 2, Every Loan Creates a Deposit

Question 4 · correct answer B

M2 is the most widely tracked broad measure in the United States and most major economies. When commentary refers to money supply without specifying, it usually means M2.

A is the narrowest and the only one directly controlled, but not the most watched. C excludes savings and short-term deposits. D is the widest, and the Federal Reserve stopped publishing it in 2006.

Review: Section 4, Measuring the Money

Question 5 · correct answer B

A shrinking money supply signals credit tightening and is treated as a deflationary warning, usually alongside economic stress.

A describes rapid M2 growth, the opposite case. C overstates it, since currency effects depend on what other economies are doing at the same time. D is wrong because M2 is watched precisely for its signaling value.

Review: Section 4, Measuring the Money

Question 6 · correct answer A

Mild inflation gently discourages sitting on cash, and a positive target keeps distance from deflation, which is self-reinforcing and hard to escape.

B confuses an outcome with a reason. C describes an effect some argue about but not the stated purpose. D invents an agreement that does not exist, though the target is widely shared.

Review: Section 5, Why Two Percent

Question 7 · correct answer D

At two percent a year, purchasing power halves in about thirty-five years. Roughly one working life.

A and B are considerably too fast at this rate. C would correspond to an inflation rate around one percent.

Review: Section 6, Your Money Is Designed to Shrink

Question 8 · correct answer A

Both currencies in a pair lose purchasing power by design. The exchange rate reports which is losing it faster, and how expectations about that are changing.

B is wrong because under an inflation target both are losing value. C misreads a relative measure as an absolute one. D is wrong because inflation differences are among the strongest drivers of currency movement.

Review: Section 7, Why This Reaches a Chart

Keep going

Where Money Came From is written by Kanin D. Alldredge for The Currency Classroom, and it is free to read. There is more free from CNS: start here.

Start free with CNS →

Or see CNS Pro →