Crypto From First Principles · Lesson 50 · 11 min read

Stablecoins, Properly

Three Ways to Promise a Dollar
Kanin D. Alldredge
Legal & Quantitative Analyst / Author / Educator, The Currency Classroom
Free

1The Half Nobody Examines

Lesson 2 established that every price has two currencies in it. Lesson 11 pointed out that most crypto prices are quoted against a stablecoin, not against actual dollars.

So a trader looking at a crypto price studies one half of it carefully and ignores the other.

If the quote currency moves, the price moves, whatever the asset did.

Figure 50.1: Every crypto price has a quote currency, and most traders never examine it.
Figure 50.1Every crypto price has a quote currency, and most traders never examine it.

A stablecoin is designed to hold a fixed value, almost always one US dollar. When it does, it is invisible. When it does not, every price quoted against it moves at once.

So it is worth knowing what is actually holding that dollar in place.

2Three Different Promises

There are three ways to make a token worth a dollar. They have almost nothing in common except the result they aim at.

TypeHow the Dollar Is HeldExample
Fiat-backedReal dollars or dollar assets held in reserve, one for oneUSDT, USDC
Crypto-backedMore than a dollar of volatile crypto locked as collateralDAI (now alongside USDS)
AlgorithmicNothing held. Code adjusts supply to push the price backTerraUSD, formerly
Figure 50.2: Three ways to promise a dollar, and what stands behind each token.
Figure 50.2Three ways to promise a dollar, and what stands behind each token.

Lesson 34 gave the framework for these. A fiat-backed stablecoin is a currency board. The mechanism holds reserves against every unit issued. An algorithmic one is a promise resting on belief, with no reserve underneath.

Lesson 34 also explained why that difference is not a matter of degree. A currency board removes the decision point. A promise still has one.

3Three Different Ways to Break

Because the backing differs, the failure differs. That is the practical reason to know which type you hold.

TypeHow It FailsHow Fast
Fiat-backedReserves are insufficient, unverified, or inaccessible when neededHours to days, and often recoverable
Crypto-backedCollateral falls faster than the buffer absorbs, and forced selling amplifies the fallRapid, during severe downturns
AlgorithmicConfidence goes, and the restoring mechanism reverses into a spiralVery fast, and usually terminal
Figure 50.3: Each type breaks differently, and on a different timescale.
Figure 50.3Each type breaks differently, and on a different timescale.

Read the third row carefully, because it contains something dangerous.

An algorithmic stablecoin relies on participants having a profitable reason to trade the price back toward a dollar whenever it drifts. Under normal conditions that works. Under stress, when everyone wants out at once, the incentive flips. Participants race for the exit instead. The mechanism built to restore stability accelerates the collapse.

The repair mechanism becomes the demolition mechanism.

Figure 50.4: Under stress, an algorithmic peg's restoring mechanism runs in reverse.
Figure 50.4Under stress, an algorithmic peg's restoring mechanism runs in reverse.

4A Peg That Bent and Recovered

In March 2023 a major fiat-backed stablecoin, USDC, briefly lost its dollar.

Its issuer disclosed that 3.3 billion dollars of reserves sat at a bank that had just failed. The token traded as low as about eighty-seven cents. A discount of roughly thirteen percent.

The important detail is what the concern actually was.

The Worry Was NotThe Worry Was
That the reserves did not existWhether they could be reached
That the issuer had liedWhether redemptions would function during the bank's failure

When authorities confirmed the bank's depositors would be made whole, confidence returned. The peg recovered fully within about forty-eight hours.

Figure 50.5: USDC lost its dollar briefly in March 2023, then recovered.
Figure 50.5USDC lost its dollar briefly in March 2023, then recovered.
Figure 50.6: The three requirements for a fiat-backed peg.
Figure 50.6The three requirements for a fiat-backed peg.

5A Peg That Did Not Recover

In May 2022 an algorithmic stablecoin failed completely. Roughly forty billion dollars of combined value was destroyed in a matter of days.

There was no reserve to deploy. Only the mechanism. Once confidence went, it worked in reverse, exactly as Section 3 describes.

What makes this worth studying rather than just noting is that the stress was visible in advance.

The SignalWhat It Meant
The emergency reserve was modest against the tokens in circulationThe backstop could not have covered a broad exit
That reserve was being spent, visibly, in the days beforeLesson 35 called reserve depletion the first mechanism, and it was observable
Deposits were being paid about 20 percent a yearThe demand holding the system together was being bought
Figure 50.7: The warning signs visible before TerraUSD collapsed.
Figure 50.7The warning signs visible before TerraUSD collapsed.

The last row deserves the comparison it invites.

Lesson 35 described the Bank of England raising rates toward fifteen percent in one day to defend sterling. The defense failed partly because it was so extreme that nobody believed it could last. The attempt advertised desperation rather than strength.

A protocol paying twenty percent a year to hold its peg is that same signal, in a different alphabet.

Figure 50.8: The same signal of desperation, thirty years apart.
Figure 50.8The same signal of desperation, thirty years apart.

6The Framework Transfers Exactly

Which is the deeper point of this lesson. It is also why the lesson sits here in the course rather than the beginning.

Lesson 35 listed five ways a currency peg breaks. Every one has a stablecoin equivalent.

From Lesson 35In a Stablecoin
Reserve depletionThe backstop being spent, visibly, before the break
Fundamental misalignmentA promise the backing cannot actually support
Speculative attackCoordinated selling that starts the confidence break
Voluntary abandonmentAn issuer choosing to stop defending the price
Credibility withdrawalBelief going, after which nothing else matters
Figure 50.9: All five ways a currency peg breaks have stablecoin equivalents.
Figure 50.9All five ways a currency peg breaks have stablecoin equivalents.

Nothing in that table needed new knowledge. A trader who understood why sterling broke in 1992, and why the Swiss floor was withdrawn in 2015, already had the tools to assess a stablecoin.

Which says something about how this course has been built. Pattern recognition across asset classes is worth something on its own. Treating crypto as a separate universe throws away everything Series F established.

7What This Means Practically

Two consequences follow for anyone holding or quoting in a stablecoin.

The first is that the type matters more than the name. All three are called stablecoins. Treating them as equivalent because they share a label is the same error as treating all currency pegs as equally credible because they are all called pegs.

The second concerns what you actually hold. Lesson 11 made the point briefly. It is worth restating now that the mechanics are in place.

a dollar in a bank ≠ a token promising a dollar

One is a claim on an institution operating under a national framework. The other is a claim on a private issuer. Its ability to honor that claim depends on reserves you cannot inspect directly, and a redemption process you will probably never use.

Figure 50.10: A dollar in a bank and a token promising a dollar are different claims.
Figure 50.10A dollar in a bank and a token promising a dollar are different claims.

That is not an argument against using them. They serve a real function, and crypto trading would be far more awkward without them. It is an argument for knowing which of the three you hold.

8Biggest Is Not Most Transparent

One factual point remains, and it matters because most people assume the two go together.

The most widely used stablecoin and the most transparent one are not the same asset.

USDCUSDT
Reserve disclosuresWeekly, with monthly third-party attestationQuarterly attestation
Full independent auditYes, annually since 2018, within Circle's audited financial statementsFirst completed August 2026 (KPMG, for 2025)
Market positionSmallerThe largest, and the dominant quote currency

The next lesson closes the series. It sets crypto and currency side by side against the three functions of money from Lesson 29, and asks honestly which tests each one passes.

Three Things to Remember

Try This

Fifteen minutes. Two of these you can check in a browser.

Words From This Lesson

TermWhat It Means
StablecoinA token designed to hold a fixed value, almost always one US dollar.
Fiat-backedBacked by reserves of real dollars or dollar assets, one for one. A currency board analog.
Crypto-backedBacked by more than a dollar of volatile crypto locked as collateral.
AlgorithmicBacked by nothing. Code adjusts supply to push the price toward the peg.
De-pegA loss of the fixed value the token was designed to hold.
AttestationA third-party report on reserves. Less thorough than a full independent audit.
Liquidation cascadeForced selling of collateral that pushes prices lower, triggering further forced selling.

Test Your Knowledge

Eight questions. Answer them all before checking the key on the following pages. If a question gives you trouble, the answer key tells you which section to revisit.

1. Why does the stablecoin in a crypto price deserve scrutiny?
  1. A. It determines the trading hours
  2. B. If it moves, the price moves regardless of what the asset did
  3. C. It sets the spread
  4. D. It has no effect on the quote
2. How does a fiat-backed stablecoin hold its value?
  1. A. Code adjusts the supply automatically
  2. B. Over-collateralization with crypto
  3. C. Real dollars or dollar assets held in reserve
  4. D. A government guarantee
3. What is the failure mode of a crypto-backed stablecoin?
  1. A. Collateral falling faster than the buffer absorbs, with forced selling amplifying it
  2. B. Reserve opacity
  3. C. Confidence collapse in a code mechanism
  4. D. Regulatory prohibition
4. What happens to an algorithmic stablecoin's mechanism under stress?
  1. A. It restores the peg more aggressively
  2. B. It pauses automatically
  3. C. The incentives reverse and it accelerates the collapse
  4. D. It converts to fiat backing
5. In the March 2023 de-peg, what was the actual concern?
  1. A. The reserves did not exist
  2. B. The blockchain had failed
  3. C. The issuer had committed fraud
  4. D. Whether the reserves could be accessed during a bank failure
6. What were the three conditions for a fiat-backed peg to hold?
  1. A. Fixed supply, mining, and consensus
  2. B. Low volatility, high volume, and regulation
  3. C. Government backing, audits, and insurance
  4. D. Reserves exist, are accessible, and are believed in
7. A protocol paying about 20 percent a year on deposits resembles what from Lesson 35?
  1. A. An unsustainable interest rate defense of a peg
  2. B. A currency board arrangement
  3. C. Normal money market returns
  4. D. A central bank swap agreement
8. What is true of the largest stablecoin by market capitalization?
  1. A. It is also the most transparent
  2. B. It is not the most transparent, and had not completed a full independent audit as of early 2026
  3. C. It is fully audited monthly by regulators
  4. D. It is algorithmic

Answer Key

Each answer explains why the correct choice is correct, why the others are not, and where to reread.

Question 1 · correct answer B

Every price has two currencies in it. Most crypto prices are quoted against a stablecoin, so if that stablecoin loses its value the price changes whatever the asset did.

A is unrelated, since crypto markets run continuously. C describes a cost that exists independently of the quote currency's stability. D is the assumption this lesson exists to correct.

Review: Section 1, The Half Nobody Examines

Question 2 · correct answer C

Reserves of actual dollars or dollar-denominated assets are held against every token issued, which makes it a currency board analog in Lesson 34's terms.

A describes an algorithmic stablecoin. B describes a crypto-backed one. D is wrong because no government guarantees these tokens.

Review: Section 2, Three Different Promises

Question 3 · correct answer A

The collateral is volatile. In a severe downturn it can fall faster than the over-collateralization buffer absorbs, and the liquidation designed to protect the peg adds to the selling.

B is the fiat-backed failure mode. C is the algorithmic one. D describes an external event rather than a structural weakness.

Review: Section 3, Three Different Ways to Break

Question 4 · correct answer C

The design assumes participants have a profitable reason to trade the price back toward a dollar. Under stress that incentive flips and everyone races for the exit instead.

A describes what the design intends and not what happens under stress. B invents a pause that does not exist. D is wrong because no such conversion is possible.

Review: Section 3, Three Different Ways to Break

Question 5 · correct answer D

Reserves of 3.3 billion dollars were held at a bank that had just failed. The question was accessibility during the resolution, not existence, and the peg recovered once deposits were guaranteed.

A and C both misstate the situation, since the reserves were real and disclosed. B is wrong because no technical failure was involved.

Review: Section 4, A Peg That Bent and Recovered

Question 6 · correct answer D

The reserves must exist in the amount claimed, be reachable when needed, and be believed in by participants. The third can fail on its own.

B lists market characteristics rather than peg requirements. C describes protections these tokens do not carry. A describes blockchain mechanics from Lesson 48.

Review: Section 4, A Peg That Bent and Recovered

Question 7 · correct answer A

Paying an extraordinary rate to hold demand in place is the same signal as raising interest rates to an unsustainable level to defend a currency. The defense advertises the difficulty.

B describes a mechanism with reserves behind it, which is the opposite arrangement. C badly understates a rate far above ordinary returns. D describes an arrangement between central banks.

Review: Section 5, A Peg That Did Not Recover

Question 8 · correct answer B

The most widely used and the most transparent are not the same asset. As of early 2026 the largest published quarterly attestations but had not completed a full independent audit. Its first, by KPMG, was announced in August 2026.

A is the common assumption and it is incorrect. C overstates the current requirements, though legislation from July 2025 moves in that direction. D is wrong because the largest is fiat-backed.

Review: Section 8, Biggest Is Not Most Transparent

Keep going

Crypto From First Principles is written by Kanin D. Alldredge for The Currency Classroom, and it is free to read. There is more free from CNS: start here.

Start free with CNS →

Or see CNS Pro →