The Market Today · Lesson 41 · 11 min read

Where Prices Come From

Most of the Volume Is Not Speculation
Kanin D. Alldredge
Legal & Quantitative Analyst / Author / Educator, The Currency Classroom
Free

1The Question Behind the Number

Lesson 40 gave the headline figure. Average daily turnover of $9.6 trillion.

A reasonable assumption is that this is a measure of trading. Millions of participants forming views on direction and acting on them, at enormous scale.

It is not, and the gap between the assumption and the reality is large.

InstrumentShare of TurnoverWhat It Is Mainly For
FX swapsAbout 42 percentManaging cash and funding across dates
SpotAbout 31 percentStraightforward exchange, settled in two business days
Outright forwardsAbout 19 percentFixing a rate for a known future payment
Options and otherAbout 7 percentProtection with a choice attached
Figure 41.1: Daily turnover by instrument. Only spot is what most people mean by trading.
Figure 41.1Daily turnover by instrument. Only spot is what most people mean by trading.

Only one of those four rows is what most people mean by trading. And it is not the biggest. The shares are the survey's rounded figures, so they do not add to exactly 100.

2Spot, the Familiar One

A spot transaction is the direct purchase of one currency for another, settled within two business days.

This is what financial media quotes. When someone says the price of EUR/USD, they mean the spot rate. It is the simplest form of currency exchange and the one every other instrument is priced from.

It accounts for about 31 percent of the total.

Slightly under a third of the market's volume is straightforward exchange of one currency for another. The other two thirds is doing something else.

3The Largest Instrument, and Almost Nobody Knows It

An FX swap is a simultaneous purchase and sale of the same amount of a currency, at two different dates. One leg now, one leg later.

It sounds pointless described that way. An example makes it obvious.

Figure 41.2: An FX swap bridges the gap between when money is needed and when it arrives.
Figure 41.2An FX swap bridges the gap between when money is needed and when it arrives.

This is the largest single category in the market, at about 42 percent. More than spot. More than any instrument used to bet on direction.

The biggest thing happening in this market is treasury management.

4Forwards, and Removing Uncertainty

A forward contract is a binding agreement to exchange a set amount of currency at a fixed rate on a specified future date.

Lesson 1 described a French company selling to American customers, paid in dollars, with costs in euros. Here is the problem that creates, and the tool that solves it.

The company knows a payment of a certain size arrives in ninety days. It does not know what the rate will be then. Which means it cannot know what those dollars will be worth in euros, and therefore cannot budget.

A forward removes the uncertainty. The rate is fixed today for a transaction ninety days out.

Notice what the company has given up. If the rate moves in their favor they do not benefit, because they are locked in. They accepted that deliberately, because certainty was worth more than the possible gain.

Figure 41.3: A forward trades possible gains for a rate that is known in advance.
Figure 41.3A forward trades possible gains for a rate that is known in advance.

Forwards are about 19 percent of turnover. Almost none of it is anyone trying to profit from a move.

5Two Complications Worth Knowing

Forwards raise a question with a satisfying answer, and they have a variant that connects directly to Lesson 34.

The question first. If a forward fixes a rate for ninety days out, what rate is that? Not simply today's price, and the difference is not a guess about the future.

forward rate = spot ± the interest rate difference
Figure 41.4: A forward rate sits away from spot by roughly the interest rate difference.
Figure 41.4A forward rate sits away from spot by roughly the interest rate difference.

If one currency pays a higher interest rate than the other, its forward rate is lower than its spot rate by roughly that difference. Otherwise there would be a risk-free profit available, and it would be taken until it disappeared.

Figure 41.5: One interest rate difference shows up in two places.
Figure 41.5One interest rate difference shows up in two places.

Now the variant. Lesson 34 covered currencies whose movement across borders is restricted. Those cannot be delivered freely, so an ordinary forward will not work.

A non-deliverable forward solves it. Rather than exchanging the currencies at maturity, the two parties settle the difference between the agreed rate and the actual rate, paid in a freely usable currency such as dollars.

Nobody ever holds the restricted currency. The exposure is hedged anyway. This is how institutions manage risk in currencies they cannot practically obtain.

Figure 41.6: A non-deliverable forward settles only the difference, in a freely usable currency.
Figure 41.6A non-deliverable forward settles only the difference, in a freely usable currency.

6Options, Briefly

A currency option gives the right, but not the obligation, to exchange at a fixed rate by a specified date.

The difference from a forward is the word obligation. A forward binds you. An option lets you walk away and use the market rate instead if that turns out better.

Figure 41.7: A forward binds you. An option lets you walk away.
Figure 41.7A forward binds you. An option lets you walk away.

That flexibility is paid for up front. Options are about 7 percent of turnover, used mainly by corporations and institutions that want protection while keeping the upside.

7What You Are Actually Holding

Now the part that surprises people.

When an individual opens a position on a retail platform, they are almost certainly not buying or selling currency.

They are entering a contract whose value is derived from the exchange rate between two currencies. No euros are acquired. No dollars change hands. The contract tracks the rate, and the result is settled in the account's own currency.

What a Spot Transaction DoesWhat a Retail Position Does
Currency is actually exchangedNo currency is exchanged
Settles in two business daysRuns until you close it
Between two institutionsBetween you and your provider
You end up holding a currencyYou end up holding a result
Figure 41.8: A spot transaction exchanges currency. A retail position tracks the rate.
Figure 41.8A spot transaction exchanges currency. A retail position tracks the rate.

Which reframes Lesson 4. Going long EUR/USD means holding euros and giving up dollars, and that description is exactly right about what your position tracks. What it does not describe is a physical exchange, because none occurs.

This is not a criticism of the arrangement. Direct participation in the spot market requires everything Lesson 40 listed, and the derivative structure is what makes access possible at all. But knowing what you hold is better than assuming.

8How to Read the Number Now

Return to the $9.6 trillion with everything above in view.

What People AssumeWhat the Data Says
It measures trading activityMost of it is funding, hedging, and settlement
It shows how many people are betting on directionSpeculation is a minority of a minority
A bigger number means more speculationA bigger number can mean more corporate hedging

Which vindicates something Lesson 1 said early and briefly. Most of the daily volume is not speculation or strategy. It is the plumbing of the global economy.

Two practical consequences follow.

The first is about liquidity. The depth that lets you enter and exit easily is largely produced by participants who are not trying to predict anything. Corporate hedging flows and bank funding operations create the market you trade inside, which is a more comfortable thought than the alternative.

Figure 41.9: The liquidity you trade in comes largely from participants who are not predicting anything.
Figure 41.9The liquidity you trade in comes largely from participants who are not predicting anything.

The survey has run since 1989, when daily turnover was about $590 billion. It is now roughly sixteen times that.

Figure 41.10: Average daily turnover has grown roughly sixteen times since the first survey.
Figure 41.10Average daily turnover has grown roughly sixteen times since the first survey.

The next lesson asks who is behind all of it. Lesson 5 gave a pyramid and a rough ordering. This time the shares are measured, and the answer contains at least one number most retail traders would not guess.

Three Things to Remember

Try This

Fifteen minutes. Mostly thinking, with one piece of arithmetic.

Words From This Lesson

TermWhat It Means
Spot transactionDirect exchange of one currency for another, settled within two business days. About 31 percent of turnover.
FX swapA simultaneous purchase and sale of the same amount at two different dates. Used for funding, not direction. The largest category at about 42 percent.
Forward contractA binding agreement to exchange at a fixed rate on a future date. Used to remove uncertainty from a known future payment.
Non-deliverable forwardA forward on a restricted currency, settled as a cash difference in a usable currency rather than by exchange.
Currency optionThe right, but not the obligation, to exchange at a fixed rate by a set date. Flexibility paid for up front.
DerivativeA contract whose value comes from something else. A retail currency position is one.
SettlementThe point at which a transaction is completed and currency actually changes hands.

Test Your Knowledge

Eight questions. Answer them all before checking the key on the following pages. If a question gives you trouble, the answer key tells you which section to revisit.

1. Which instrument accounts for the largest share of daily turnover?
  1. A. Spot transactions
  2. B. Outright forwards
  3. C. FX swaps
  4. D. Currency options
2. Roughly what share of turnover is spot?
  1. A. About 7 percent
  2. B. About 19 percent
  3. C. About 31 percent
  4. D. About 42 percent
3. What is an FX swap primarily used for?
  1. A. Managing cash and funding across different dates
  2. B. Betting on direction with less risk
  3. C. Hedging a corporate payment 90 days out
  4. D. Speculating on interest rate changes
4. A company will receive dollars in 90 days and wants certainty about their value in euros. Which instrument fits?
  1. A. A forward contract
  2. B. A spot transaction
  3. C. An FX swap
  4. D. A currency option, necessarily
5. What sets the difference between a spot rate and a forward rate?
  1. A. A forecast of where the price will be
  2. B. The interest rate difference between the two currencies
  3. C. The size of the transaction
  4. D. The credit rating of the counterparty
6. What is a non-deliverable forward for?
  1. A. Very large transactions
  2. B. Trades between central banks
  3. C. Transactions settling in under two days
  4. D. Currencies that cannot be freely exchanged
7. What is a retail trader actually holding when they open a position?
  1. A. The base currency of the pair
  2. B. A contract whose value derives from the exchange rate
  3. C. A share of an interbank spot transaction
  4. D. A forward contract with a fixed maturity
8. Why should the $9.6 trillion figure be quoted with care?
  1. A. It is an estimate with a wide margin of error
  2. B. It has not been updated since 2022
  3. C. It excludes the largest instrument category
  4. D. It was measured during a month of unusually high volatility

Answer Key

Each answer explains why the correct choice is correct, why the others are not, and where to reread.

Question 1 · correct answer C

FX swaps are about 42 percent of daily turnover, more than any other category, and they are used for funding rather than for taking a view on direction.

A is about 31 percent and is the instrument most like trading. B is about 19 percent. D is about 7 percent.

Review: Section 1, The Question Behind the Number

Question 2 · correct answer C

Spot is about 31 percent, slightly under a third. The remaining two thirds is doing something other than straightforward exchange.

A corresponds to options. B corresponds to outright forwards. D corresponds to FX swaps, the largest category.

Review: Section 2, Spot, the Familiar One

Question 3 · correct answer A

A swap bridges the gap between when money is needed and when it arrives. Currency exposure at the end matches the start, so no view on direction is involved.

B misreads the purpose entirely, since a swap is designed to leave exposure unchanged. C describes an outright forward. D describes a different kind of position altogether.

Review: Section 3, The Largest Instrument

Question 4 · correct answer A

A forward fixes the rate today for a transaction on a specified future date, which removes the uncertainty from a known future payment.

B settles in two business days and does nothing about a payment three months out. C is for bridging funding gaps rather than hedging a future receipt. D can work but costs a premium, so it is not the necessary answer.

Review: Section 4, Forwards, and Removing Uncertainty

Question 5 · correct answer B

The forward rate is the spot rate adjusted by the interest rate difference between the two currencies. Anything else would create a risk-free profit that would be taken until it vanished.

A is the intuitive answer and it is wrong, since the gap is arithmetic rather than a prediction. C and D can affect pricing at the margin but neither sets the relationship.

Review: Section 5, Two Complications Worth Knowing

Question 6 · correct answer D

Where a currency cannot be freely exchanged, the parties settle the difference between the agreed rate and the actual rate in a usable currency instead. The restricted currency never changes hands.

A is unrelated to size. C describes spot settlement. B invents a restriction on who may use the instrument.

Review: Section 5, Two Complications Worth Knowing

Question 7 · correct answer B

No currency is acquired and none changes hands. The contract tracks the rate, and the result settles in the account's own currency.

A describes what a spot transaction does. C is wrong because retail orders do not become part of an interbank transaction. D is wrong because a retail position has no fixed maturity and runs until closed.

Review: Section 7, What You Are Actually Holding

Question 8 · correct answer D

The survey was taken in April, during a period of elevated trade policy volatility, so it likely reflects a busier than average month rather than typical conditions.

A misstates the issue, since the survey is authoritative and the concern is the window rather than the method. C is wrong because it includes all categories. B is wrong because the 2025 figure is the most recent.

Review: Section 8, How to Read the Number Now

Keep going

The Market Today is written by Kanin D. Alldredge for The Currency Classroom, and it is free to read. There is more free from CNS: start here.

Start free with CNS →

Or see CNS Pro →