The Dollar's Position · Lesson 39 · 13 min read

The Challengers

Three Candidates, Three Different Walls
Kanin D. Alldredge
Legal & Quantitative Analyst / Author / Educator, The Currency Classroom
Free

1Three Serious Candidates

There are three. Not a long list, and each is serious in a different way.

CandidateWhat It Is Today
The euroSecond reserve currency, about 20 percent of reserves
The Chinese yuanAbout 2 percent, after peaking near 3 percent in 2022
BitcoinHeld by a few institutions and one national government
Figure 39.1: The three serious candidates to challenge the dollar.
Figure 39.1The three serious candidates to challenge the dollar.

Each is usually judged on its own. What emerges when you put all three together is more interesting, and it is the subject of Section 8.

Take them in order.

2The Euro Has Four of Five

The euro is the strongest candidate by a distance. It is worth being clear how much it already has.

Condition from Lesson 36The Euro
Deep, liquid marketsYes. Large and liquid.
Rule of lawYes. Strong protections, independent courts.
Capital account opennessYes. Money moves freely.
Geopolitical credibilityYes. Stable and established.
Network scaleSubstantial. Already second.

On the five conditions, the euro does well. So why has it been stuck at roughly a fifth of global reserves for twenty years?

The answer sits underneath the first condition.

Figure 39.2: The euro meets the five conditions, with a crack under the first.
Figure 39.2The euro meets the five conditions, with a crack under the first.

3What the Euro Is Missing

The eurozone is a monetary union without a fiscal union.

One central bank sets rates for every member. But each member government runs its own budget, sets its own taxes, and issues its own debt.

That gap matters enormously for a reserve asset.

There is no single eurozone government bond.

A central bank holding dollars buys United States government debt, from one issuer. A central bank holding euros must choose between member states, and they are not equally safe.

Figure 39.3: Holding dollars means one issuer. Holding euros means choosing between member states.
Figure 39.3Holding dollars means one issuer. Holding euros means choosing between member states.
Figure 39.4: The sovereign debt crisis tested the euro's safety, and the test went badly.
Figure 39.4The sovereign debt crisis tested the euro's safety, and the test went badly.

The fix is known and it is not technical. A common eurozone treasury. Common debt backed by the whole bloc. An explicit lender of last resort.

Each step requires member governments to hand fiscal control to a supranational body. Several have consistently declined, for democratic rather than economic reasons.

Figure 39.5: The fix is known, and its price is political.
Figure 39.5The fix is known, and its price is political.

So the euro's ceiling is political. It will likely stay the world's second reserve currency at roughly its current share. On the present path it is not a candidate to displace the dollar.

4The Yuan Has Built the Most

Where the euro's problem is too little integration, the yuan's runs the other way.

China has made the most systematic effort to build reserve currency infrastructure of any challenger since the war. That deserves stating plainly, before the constraint.

What Has Been BuiltWhat It Does
About forty central bank swap agreementsEach one reduces the need for dollar intermediation in that trading relationship
Inclusion in the IMF's reserve asset basket, 2016Formal recognition that the yuan had reached international usage
Loans denominated in yuan under the Belt and Road InitiativeCreates countries with yuan obligations, and therefore a structural reason to hold yuan
A domestic cross-border payment systemAn alternative route for settlement outside existing networks
Figure 39.6: What China has built, including yuan debt that copies the dollar's mechanism.
Figure 39.6What China has built, including yuan debt that copies the dollar's mechanism.

Look at the third row against Lesson 36. Debt in a currency creates compulsory demand for it, because the obligation must be serviced. That is the same mechanism behind dollar debt, deliberately copied.

The results are real but modest. From effectively zero in 2015 to about 2 percent now, after peaking near 3 percent in 2022. That is the fastest growth of any currency in the reserve data, and still a small share.

Figure 39.7: The fastest growth in the reserve data, still a small share.
Figure 39.7The fastest growth in the reserve data, still a small share.

5The Yuan's Constraint Is a Choice

The yuan fails on capital account openness. Lesson 36 called it the most precise of the five conditions, because capital either moves freely or it does not.

China restricts how money moves in and out. So a country holding large yuan reserves cannot be sure of deploying or repatriating them freely when needed. A reserve you cannot use on demand is not doing the job.

The important part is why.

This is not a gap waiting to be closed. It is a decision, and it has costs on both sides.

Opening the capital account fully would mean giving up much control over domestic credit and where capital goes. That control is valued. The price of keeping it is a ceiling on the currency's international role.

So the yuan's constraint is not a problem anybody is trying to solve. It is a trade-off already made. It could be unmade, but only by accepting something China has judged not worth accepting.

Figure 39.8: The yuan's capital controls are a trade-off already made.
Figure 39.8The yuan's capital controls are a trade-off already made.

6What Bitcoin Actually Solves

The third candidate is different in kind, and the case for it deserves serious consideration.

Bitcoin does not try to match the dollar's properties. It targets specific weaknesses in the current arrangement, and Series F identified every one of them.

The WeaknessWhere This Course Covered ItBitcoin's Answer
The Triffin DilemmaLesson 33No issuer, so nobody must run deficits to supply it
Supply expanded by policyLesson 30A fixed supply of 21 million, set in the protocol
The exorbitant privilegeLesson 38No country issues it, so no country gains the advantages
Figure 39.9: The structural weaknesses Bitcoin targets.
Figure 39.9The structural weaknesses Bitcoin targets.

Those are not small points. Each one targets something this course has documented as a real structural problem.

Some governments have begun treating it as a reserve asset. El Salvador made it legal tender in 2021, then in early 2025 amended the law so businesses no longer have to accept it. In March 2025 the United States created a Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, holding bitcoin it already owned through forfeitures, and New Hampshire and Texas passed laws that year allowing their states to hold it. The logic is consistent. A hedge against debasement, behaving less like money and more like digital gold, with scarcity guaranteed by mathematics rather than promised by an institution.

7What Disqualifies It Today

Against the five conditions, Bitcoin currently fails three. The first is decisive.

The ProblemWhy It Disqualifies
VolatilityBitcoin has moved 40 to 80 percent within single calendar years, in both directions. Reserves are held precisely to be stable when other things are falling.
No lender of last resortIn a liquidity crisis a central bank can supply dollars without limit. Bitcoin's supply is fixed and cannot be expanded to meet one.
Custody at sovereign scaleHolding it securely at central bank size requires key management and security infrastructure most institutions have not built.
Figure 39.10: What disqualifies Bitcoin as a reserve asset today.
Figure 39.10What disqualifies Bitcoin as a reserve asset today.

The second row is the one most often skipped, and it is a real problem rather than a preference. Lesson 35 showed a central bank supplying currency without limit to defend a commitment. Lesson 38 showed the Federal Reserve meeting a compulsory global demand for dollars in 2008. A fixed supply cannot do either. And that is the same property the case for Bitcoin rests on.

Figure 39.11: The same fixed supply makes the case for Bitcoin and disqualifies it.
Figure 39.11The same fixed supply makes the case for Bitcoin and disqualifies it.
Figure 39.12: What drives Bitcoin's price now.
Figure 39.12What drives Bitcoin's price now.

8Three Walls, No Two the Same

Now put the three together. This is where the useful observation is.

CandidateFails OnWhy
The euroA single risk-free assetNo unified borrower, and the fix requires political integration members decline
The yuanCapital account opennessRestrictions are a deliberate choice with a real domestic benefit
BitcoinStability and crisis liquidityVolatility, and a fixed supply that cannot expand when needed

No two fail on the same condition. So the dollar is not facing one consolidated alternative. It faces three partial challenges. Each serious, each blocked by something different, and none able to absorb the full weight of global reserve demand.

Figure 39.13: Three candidates, three different walls.
Figure 39.13Three candidates, three different walls.

That explains something from Lesson 36 that would otherwise be puzzling.

Over Two DecadesChange in Reserve Share
The dollarDown roughly 14 percentage points
The euroUp roughly 1.5 points
The yuanUp roughly 2 points
Everything elseAbsorbed the remainder
Figure 39.14: The fourteen points the dollar lost went nowhere in particular.
Figure 39.14The fourteen points the dollar lost went nowhere in particular.

Fourteen points left the dollar and went nowhere in particular. They spread across a wider set of smaller currencies, because no candidate could be a destination for the whole of it.

De-dollarization without a destination is not dollar displacement.

What is happening is real. Diversification, running slowly, consolidating nowhere.

What This Series Was For

Four lessons ago the question was what a reserve currency is. The answer was a function that emerges when five conditions hold at once, defended by a network effect that makes incumbents very hard to move.

Then how the dollar came to hold it, what the position is worth, and who pays for it. And now the candidates, each stopped by something different.

Figure 39.15: The de-dollarization thesis runs on a timescale markets do not trade on.
Figure 39.15The de-dollarization thesis runs on a timescale markets do not trade on.

Meanwhile the measure that touches your chart has not moved. The dollar sits on one side of 89.2 percent of currency transactions, up rather than down over three years. Every major pair contains it. One dollar move still produces seven reactions. A crisis anywhere still strengthens it.

The next series returns to the market itself, and to how pairs move together.

Three Things to Remember

Try This

Twenty minutes. The last step is the one that carries forward.

Words From This Lesson

TermWhat It Means
Fiscal unionA shared budgetary authority able to tax, spend, and issue debt on behalf of a whole bloc. The eurozone has a monetary union without one.
Risk-free assetGovernment debt considered certain to be repaid, which reserve holders need somewhere to put their money.
Currency swap agreementAn arrangement between two central banks to exchange currencies, reducing the need for a third currency in between.
Special Drawing RightAn IMF reserve asset, not a currency, whose value follows a weighted basket of five currencies.
Belt and Road InitiativeA Chinese lending and infrastructure program, with loans denominated in yuan creating obligations in that currency.
Lender of last resortAn institution able to supply currency without limit during a crisis. A fixed-supply asset cannot perform this role.
De-dollarizationReduced use of the dollar. Currently diversification into many currencies rather than a shift to one successor.

Test Your Knowledge

Eight questions. Answer them all before checking the key on the following pages. If a question gives you trouble, the answer key tells you which section to revisit.

1. Which condition does the euro fail on?
  1. A. Rule of law
  2. B. Deep, liquid financial markets
  3. C. Capital account openness
  4. D. The absence of a single risk-free euro government bond
2. Why is the euro's ceiling described as political?
  1. A. European voters oppose the currency
  2. B. The ECB lacks legal authority
  3. C. The fix requires member states to hand fiscal control to a supranational body
  4. D. Non-eurozone countries block it
3. What exposed the euro's structural weakness?
  1. A. The 2008 global financial crisis
  2. B. The United Kingdom leaving the European Union
  3. C. The introduction of euro banknotes
  4. D. The 2010 to 2012 sovereign debt crisis
4. Which of these has China built to support the yuan's international role?
  1. A. Central bank swap agreements, reserve basket inclusion, and yuan-denominated lending
  2. B. A gold-backed convertibility guarantee
  3. C. Full capital account liberalization
  4. D. A fixed peg to the euro
5. Why do capital controls disqualify the yuan from reserve currency scale?
  1. A. A reserve that cannot be freely deployed or repatriated is not performing the job
  2. B. They make the currency too volatile
  3. C. They violate IMF rules
  4. D. They prevent the yuan from being traded at all
6. What structural weakness of the current system does Bitcoin genuinely address?
  1. A. Exchange rate volatility
  2. B. The Triffin Dilemma, since there is no issuer running deficits
  3. C. Slow settlement times
  4. D. The absence of a lender of last resort
7. Why does a fixed supply disqualify Bitcoin as a reserve asset today?
  1. A. It makes the price too stable
  2. B. It cannot be expanded to supply liquidity during a crisis
  3. C. It prevents institutional custody
  4. D. It requires government approval
8. Where did the dollar's lost reserve share go?
  1. A. To the euro
  2. B. To the yuan
  3. C. Dispersed across a range of smaller currencies
  4. D. Into Bitcoin holdings

Answer Key

Each answer explains why the correct choice is correct, why the others are not, and where to reread.

Question 1 · correct answer D

The eurozone is a monetary union without a fiscal union. Each member issues its own debt, so there is no single borrower whose bonds are unambiguously safe regardless of who issued them.

A is a genuine euro strength, with strong legal protections. C is also a strength, since capital moves freely. B is a strength too, as European markets are large and liquid. The euro satisfies four of the five.

Review: Section 3, What the Euro Is Missing

Question 2 · correct answer C

A common treasury, common debt, and an explicit lender of last resort would each require member governments to transfer fiscal sovereignty. Several have consistently declined, for democratic reasons.

A misstates the position, since the currency itself is not the contested question. B is wrong because the ECB has full authority over monetary policy. D is wrong because the decision rests with eurozone members.

Review: Section 3, What the Euro Is Missing

Question 3 · correct answer D

During that crisis markets began pricing the possibility that individual members could default on euro-denominated debt, which removed the unquestioned safety a reserve asset requires.

A tested the global system but did not raise this specific question about euro sovereign debt. C was an administrative step. B affected a country outside the eurozone.

Review: Section 3, What the Euro Is Missing

Question 4 · correct answer A

Roughly forty central bank swap agreements, inclusion in the IMF reserve basket in 2016, and lending denominated in yuan that creates obligations in the currency. The most systematic effort any challenger has made.

B describes an arrangement no major currency has had since 1971. C is precisely what China has declined to do. D is wrong because the yuan is managed against a basket rather than pegged to the euro.

Review: Section 4, The Yuan Has Built the Most

Question 5 · correct answer A

Reserves exist to be used when needed. If capital cannot move freely, a holder cannot be certain of deploying or repatriating them, and the holding fails its purpose.

B confuses capital controls with volatility, and controls generally reduce volatility. C is wrong because such controls are permitted. D overstates it, since the yuan is actively traded.

Review: Section 5, The Yuan's Constraint Is a Choice

Question 6 · correct answer B

The Triffin Dilemma requires an issuer running deficits to supply the world. Bitcoin has no issuer and a fixed supply, so the dilemma cannot apply to it structurally.

A reverses the position, since volatility is Bitcoin's main disqualifier. C describes a technical property unrelated to reserve currency structure. D is a weakness of Bitcoin rather than something it solves.

Review: Section 6, What Bitcoin Actually Solves

Question 7 · correct answer B

During a liquidity crisis a central bank can supply currency without limit. A fixed supply cannot expand to meet emergency demand, and that is the same property the case for Bitcoin depends on.

A reverses it, since the price is highly volatile. C describes a separate operational problem rather than a consequence of fixed supply. D invents a requirement that does not exist.

Review: Section 7, What Disqualifies It Today

Question 8 · correct answer C

About fourteen points left the dollar, roughly one and a half went to the euro and two to the yuan, and the remainder spread across a wider set of smaller currencies.

A is the common assumption, and the euro has been roughly flat for two decades. B overstates a share of about two percent. D is wrong because sovereign Bitcoin holdings remain very small.

Review: Section 8, Three Walls, No Two the Same

Keep going

The Dollar's Position is written by Kanin D. Alldredge for The Currency Classroom, and it is free to read. There is more free from CNS: start here.

Start free with CNS →

Or see CNS Pro →