The Dollar's Position · Lesson 37 · 12 min read

How the Dollar Got There

A Gold Anchor Replaced by an Oil One
Kanin D. Alldredge
Legal & Quantitative Analyst / Author / Educator, The Currency Classroom
Free

1What Replaced the Gold

Before 1971, there was a clear reason to hold dollars. Each one could be exchanged for a fixed weight of gold. That was the anchor.

On August 15, 1971 the anchor was removed, and nothing was put in its place.

That should have been a serious problem. When the backing goes, so does the reason to hold it. Or so you would think.

Instead the dollar kept its position. Part of that was inertia, as Lesson 33 said. Contracts, banking ties, and invoicing habits do not switch off when a promise ends.

But something else was built, on purpose, in the years right after. Not a monetary mechanism. A political arrangement. And it gave the world a reason to hold dollars that had nothing to do with gold, or with trusting American policy.

The gold anchor was replaced by an oil anchor.

Figure 37.1: Gold anchored the dollar until 1971. From 1974, oil did.
Figure 37.1Gold anchored the dollar until 1971. From 1974, oil did.

2Three Components

Between 1973 and 1974, talks led largely by Secretary of State Henry Kissinger produced an arrangement with Saudi Arabia. It was later extended to other major oil producers.

It had three parts, and each one supports the others.

ComponentWhat It Meant
Oil priced in dollarsGulf producers would keep pricing and selling oil exclusively in US dollars
Security guaranteesThe United States would provide military protection to the Gulf monarchies
RecyclingThe dollar revenues earned would flow back into US Treasury bonds and dollar assets
Figure 37.2: The arrangement's three parts each support the others.
Figure 37.2The arrangement's three parts each support the others.

Look at the first row and think about what it produces.

If oil is priced and sold in dollars, every country that imports oil must get dollars. Not because it trades with America. Not because it likes American policy. Because the fuel its economy runs on is overwhelmingly bought that way.

That is demand that does not depend on anyone's opinion of the dollar. Which is exactly what the system had just lost.

Figure 37.3: Every oil-importing economy has to get dollars first.
Figure 37.3Every oil-importing economy has to get dollars first.

3Not a Treaty

These arrangements were not one document with a signature page and a date. They were a set of bilateral understandings, joint commissions, and ongoing relationships, built over several years.

They were not fully disclosed at the time. What is known has emerged since, through declassified documents and historical research.

So the petrodollar system is real, documented, and consequential. It is also not a contract. No page to point to. No signatories. No clause anyone could invoke.

Figure 37.4: The petrodollar arrangement was never a treaty.
Figure 37.4The petrodollar arrangement was never a treaty.

It holds together because the interests still align. That is a different kind of durability from a legal obligation. Sometimes stronger, sometimes weaker, and never enforceable.

4The Loop, in One Transaction

The arrangement is easiest to understand by following a single ordinary transaction all the way around.

A Japanese car manufacturer needs steel.

StepWhat HappensPriced In
1Iron ore comes from AustraliaDollars
2Coking coal comes from IndonesiaDollars
3The furnace runs on natural gasDollars
4Finished cars ship on vessels burning heavy fuel oilDollars
5That fuel comes from a Singapore refineryDollars
6Which sources its crude from Saudi ArabiaDollars
Figure 37.5: Every step in one car maker's supply chain is priced in dollars.
Figure 37.5Every step in one car maker's supply chain is priced in dollars.

At every step, somebody had to get dollars. The manufacturer. The shipping company. The refinery. None of them decided anything about the dollar. They decided about steel, fuel, and shipping. The dollars followed.

Now follow where those dollars go.

The Saudi government is paid in dollars. Some of it is deposited with a bank in New York, which buys US Treasury bonds. Those bonds help fund the American deficit. That deficit funds, among much else, the naval presence in the Gulf. Which patrols the waters the original crude shipment passed through.

Figure 37.6: Where the oil dollars go next.
Figure 37.6Where the oil dollars go next.

The oil created the dollar demand. The dollar demand funded the protection. The protection sustains the oil pricing.

The loop closes. Nothing in it required anyone to decide they trusted the dollar. The structure made it automatic.

Figure 37.7: The loop runs without anyone deciding to trust the dollar.
Figure 37.7The loop runs without anyone deciding to trust the dollar.
Figure 37.8: The security component of the arrangement, still running.
Figure 37.8The security component of the arrangement, still running.

5The Exorbitant Privilege

The phrase exorbitant privilege was coined by Valery Giscard d'Estaing, who was French Finance Minister in the 1960s and later President of France. It captured a frustration that has been voiced by American trading partners for decades.

The AdvantageWhat It Means
Suppressed borrowing costsPersistent global demand for Treasury bonds holds American borrowing costs below what its finances alone would justify
Deficit without disciplineMost countries face market pressure when deficits grow. Structural demand for dollars softens that pressure considerably
A geopolitical subsidyThe world's need for dollars helps fund the military presence that helps sustain the world's need for dollars

Read the second row against Lesson 33. The Triffin Dilemma said the reserve issuer must run deficits to supply the world. This is the same fact from the other side. The obligation to run deficits is also permission to run them.

Figure 37.9: The Triffin Dilemma and the exorbitant privilege are the same fact seen from two sides.
Figure 37.9The Triffin Dilemma and the exorbitant privilege are the same fact seen from two sides.

And the third row is partly self-funding. That is unusual. Most advantages have to be paid for out of something else.

Figure 37.10: The geopolitical subsidy partly pays for itself.
Figure 37.10The geopolitical subsidy partly pays for itself.

6The Cracks Are Real

The system is under real pressure. It would be misleading to present it as unchallenged.

Russia has moved much of its energy trade out of dollars since 2022, under sanctions pressure. China and Saudi Arabia have arranged for some oil trade settled in yuan. Individual producers have priced sales in other currencies at various points.

Those are documented developments and the direction is one way.

Now the counterweight. By most estimates, roughly eighty percent of global oil trade remains priced in dollars. No official series tracks it, so treat the figure as approximate.

Figure 37.11: The pressures are real, but by most estimates roughly 80 percent of oil trade is still priced in dollars.
Figure 37.11The pressures are real, but by most estimates roughly 80 percent of oil trade is still priced in dollars.
The ClaimThe Position
Pressure on dollar oil pricing is realTrue, and documented across several producers
The direction of travel is away from the dollarTrue at the margin
The system has meaningfully unwoundNot supported by the data
Figure 37.12: Three claims about the petrodollar system, and how far the data supports each.
Figure 37.12Three claims about the petrodollar system, and how far the data supports each.

Both halves matter. Dismiss the pressure and you miss a real long-term shift. Overstate it and you expect a change the numbers do not show.

7A Story With No Source

In mid-2024 a story spread widely through financial media and social platforms.

It claimed a formal fifty-year petrodollar agreement between the United States and Saudi Arabia had expired in June 2024. And that the expiry was a historic rupture that could trigger a rapid dollar decline.

The story had everything a compelling narrative needs. A specific date. A named mechanism. A dramatic consequence.

It also had no source.

The useful contrast is with Section 6. The petrodollar system faces real, documented pressures that can be sourced and measured. None of them is a contract running out.

Figure 37.13: What separated the 2024 expiry story from a documented pressure.
Figure 37.13What separated the 2024 expiry story from a documented pressure.

A trader who dismissed the 2024 story was not being complacent about de-dollarization. They declined to act on a claim nobody could substantiate, while the real pressures stayed visible in the data.

8What Holds It Together

Step back and the shape of the last two lessons becomes clear.

The dollar's position was built at Bretton Woods in 1944 on a gold promise. That promise became impossible and was withdrawn in 1971. What kept the position was two things. Accumulated infrastructure, and a new arrangement that gave the world a practical reason to need dollars.

EraWhat Made Holding Dollars Necessary
1944 to 1971Convertibility into gold at a fixed rate
1974 onwardOil was overwhelmingly bought in them
ThroughoutContracts, invoicing, banking relationships, and debt already denominated in them
Figure 37.14: Gold, then oil, with accumulated infrastructure underneath both.
Figure 37.14Gold, then oil, with accumulated infrastructure underneath both.

The third row is the quiet one, and Lesson 36 said why it matters most. Debt issued in dollars must be repaid in dollars. Invoicing habits outlive the reasons they were adopted. Network effects defend themselves.

Which returns to the question Series F kept circling. The dollar's position is a historical outcome. Built in stages, and sustained by arrangements that could in principle change.

The next lesson asks what that position is actually worth to the country that holds it, and what it costs.

Three Things to Remember

Try This

Fifteen minutes. One of these steps is a genuinely useful habit.

Words From This Lesson

TermWhat It Means
Petrodollar systemThe arrangement under which oil is priced and sold in dollars, creating global demand for them.
Petrodollar recyclingOil revenues earned in dollars being reinvested into US Treasury bonds and dollar assets.
Exorbitant privilegeThe structural advantages the United States gains from issuing the reserve currency. Coined by Valery Giscard d'Estaing.
Treasury bondsUS government debt. The asset most reserve dollars are ultimately held in.
Bilateral understandingAn arrangement between two governments that is not a formal treaty and carries no enforceable terms.
Primary sourceAn original document or record. The thing to locate before acting on a macro narrative.

Test Your Knowledge

Eight questions. Answer them all before checking the key on the following pages. If a question gives you trouble, the answer key tells you which section to revisit.

1. What replaced gold as the practical reason to hold dollars after 1971?
  1. A. A new precious metal standard
  2. B. Higher American interest rates
  3. C. An IMF guarantee
  4. D. Oil being priced and sold in dollars
2. What were the three components of the 1973 to 1974 arrangement?
  1. A. Trade tariffs, sanctions, and quotas
  2. B. Gold, silver, and oil backing
  3. C. Oil priced in dollars, security guarantees, and revenue recycling
  4. D. Fixed exchange rates, capital controls, and IMF oversight
3. Why must a country that imports Gulf oil acquire dollars?
  1. A. Because the oil is priced and sold in dollars
  2. B. It has a trade agreement with the United States
  3. C. IMF rules require it
  4. D. Its own currency is not convertible
4. What form did the petrodollar arrangements take?
  1. A. A series of bilateral understandings and ongoing relationships
  2. B. A single signed treaty with a fifty-year term
  3. C. A United Nations resolution
  4. D. An OPEC founding charter
5. In the loop described in Section 4, what do recycled oil revenues typically buy?
  1. A. Gold reserves
  2. B. Shares in oil companies
  3. C. US Treasury bonds and dollar assets
  4. D. Foreign currency other than dollars
6. What does the term exorbitant privilege describe?
  1. A. OPEC's ability to set oil prices
  2. B. Structural advantages the United States gains from issuing the reserve currency
  3. C. The IMF's voting structure
  4. D. The right to devalue a currency without approval
7. Roughly what share of global oil trade remains priced in dollars?
  1. A. About 40 percent
  2. B. About 60 percent
  3. C. About 95 percent
  4. D. About 80 percent
8. What was wrong with the 2024 story about a fifty-year petrodollar agreement expiring?
  1. A. The date was slightly incorrect
  2. B. No such agreement is documented to exist, since the arrangements were never a treaty
  3. C. It applied only to Saudi Arabia, not all producers
  4. D. The expiry was later extended

Answer Key

Each answer explains why the correct choice is correct, why the others are not, and where to reread.

Question 1 · correct answer D

Pricing oil in dollars meant every oil-importing country needed dollars regardless of its opinion of the United States. That is demand independent of confidence, which is what gold convertibility had previously supplied.

A is wrong because no metal standard returned. C invents a guarantee the IMF never gave. B describes a policy that affects the currency without anchoring global demand for it.

Review: Section 1, What Replaced the Gold

Question 2 · correct answer C

Gulf producers would keep pricing oil in dollars, the United States would provide security guarantees, and the resulting dollar revenues would be recycled into Treasury bonds and dollar assets.

B describes backing arrangements that did not exist. A lists trade instruments unrelated to the arrangement. D describes elements of Bretton Woods, which had already collapsed.

Review: Section 2, Three Components

Question 3 · correct answer A

If oil is sold in dollars, then any country needing oil must obtain dollars. The requirement follows from the pricing convention rather than from any relationship with America.

B is unnecessary, since the requirement applies to countries with no such agreement. C invents a rule. D is wrong because even fully convertible currencies must still be exchanged for dollars to buy oil.

Review: Section 2, Three Components

Question 4 · correct answer A

They were understandings, joint commissions, and continuing diplomatic relationships built over several years, not a single instrument with signatories and terms.

B is the widely repeated claim that Section 7 shows has no documentary basis. C and D describe formal multilateral instruments that were not the mechanism here.

Review: Section 3, Not a Treaty

Question 5 · correct answer C

Recycling means the dollar revenues flow back into US government debt and dollar-denominated assets, which sustains demand for both the currency and the bonds.

A describes what a pre-1971 arrangement might have involved. B and D happen at the margins but are not the mechanism that closes the loop.

Review: Section 4, The Loop, in One Transaction

Question 6 · correct answer B

It covers suppressed borrowing costs, the ability to run deficits without normal market pressure, and a partly self-funding geopolitical subsidy. Coined by a French finance minister expressing a long-standing frustration.

A describes OPEC's role, which is a different power. C describes an institutional arrangement unrelated to the term. D describes a policy option available to many countries.

Review: Section 5, The Exorbitant Privilege

Question 7 · correct answer D

Roughly eighty percent, by most estimates. Pressures on that share are real and documented, but the system has not meaningfully unwound.

A and B understate the current position considerably. C overstates it and ignores genuine movement at the margin.

Review: Section 6, The Cracks Are Real

Question 8 · correct answer B

No government document or credible historical record identifies such an agreement. There was never a single treaty, so there was nothing with an expiry date to run out.

A implies the agreement existed with a different date, which it did not. C and D both accept the premise that a formal agreement existed, which is the part with no source behind it.

Review: Section 7, A Story With No Source

Keep going

The Dollar's Position is written by Kanin D. Alldredge for The Currency Classroom, and it is free to read. There is more free from CNS: start here.

Start free with CNS →

Or see CNS Pro →